Practitioners rarely deviate from FHWA traffic control standards
1 min readThe Government Accountability Office reported Monday 16 November 2026 that almost all traffic engineers and other practitioners it interviewed said they had never or rarely deviated from the Federal Highway Administration's Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices for Streets and Highways.
Almost all practitioners viewed the Manual as the authoritative source of standards and guidance for traffic control devices. FHWA allows deviations under certain conditions, including protecting vulnerable road users. Many practitioners said deviations risked reducing uniformity.
Several practitioners reported occasional deviations to save costs or address local issues affecting efficiency or safety. Some traffic engineers were reluctant to deviate because of the possibility of a lawsuit if a crash occurred where the deviation had been made.
Safety organizations have expressed concerns that engineers may be unwilling to deviate even when doing so could make roadways safer for pedestrians, cyclists and other vulnerable road users.
FHWA revises and updates the Manual and considers practitioner change requests and successful experiments involving new devices or applications. Examples in the 11th Edition (2023) include traffic control devices intended to improve safety for vulnerable road users.
GAO reviewed the Manual, FHWA's Official Rulings Database, relevant regulations and statutes. It interviewed agency officials, practitioners from a non-generalizable sample of 26 city, county, and state jurisdictions nationwide, and traffic engineers and other practitioners from five selected professional membership organizations.



