Monday 16 November 2026Search
Politics

GAO found P.L. 280 can impede tribal self-determination

1 min read

The Government Accountability Office (GAO) reported that Tribes and the federal government generally share jurisdiction over certain crimes in Indian country. Tribes in states subject to Public Law 280 generally shared criminal jurisdiction with their state when a tribal citizen committed a crime or was a crime victim in certain circumstances.

GAO said some Tribes and local law enforcement agencies had entered into cross-deputization agreements. These agreements generally gave tribal police officers the same or similar jurisdiction and related authorities as local law enforcement officers within and outside Indian country.

Some states had returned criminal jurisdiction provided by P.L. 280 to the federal government through retrocession. Tribal leaders said retrocession enhanced their Tribes’ exercise of self-determination and addressed challenges working with state law enforcement. State law enforcement officials said Tribes could lose access to state public safety and justice services under retrocession.

GAO said federal law prevented Tribes from initiating retrocession. Tribal consent was not required when states initiated the process. Without amendments to address this, the report said the law impeded Tribes’ exercise of self-determination.

GAO’s analysis of Bureau of Indian Affairs funding data showed that from fiscal years 2017 through 2021, Tribes in states named in P.L. 280 received less funding per capita than Tribes in all other states. BIA officials said they had limited discretionary funding and generally prioritized Tribes that did not receive public safety and justice services from their states.

Public Law 280 rescinded most federal criminal jurisdiction in Indian country in select states in 1953 and provided it to those states instead. As of October 2026, approximately 65 percent of the 575 federally recognized Tribes were located in these states. GAO said prior research suggested the law may adversely affect public safety and justice through slow police response times and limited access to certain federal funding.